In an earlier post, http://tanakhemet.blogspot.com/2018/07/is-oral-law-good-idea.html
I explained why the Oral Law is not a good idea. Questions of its authenticity aside, the method of oral transmission of a vast and complex legal system is definitely not a good idea.
The Talmud (Temurah 16a-b) goes so far to say that when Moses died, 3000 laws were forgotten by the next generation , i.e. Joshua and his leadership.
see: https://steinsaltz.org/daf/temurah-16a-b-forgetting-torah-laws/
These are supposed oral laws. Now this itself is an interesting topic of discussion, but in essence, the Talmud itself is providing evidence that supports my claim. If Joshua could forget 3000 laws which Moses allegedly taught him, then the oral law is a complete disaster.
Again, this claim by the Talmud must be scrutinized, but that is for a later occasion. It is important to note that the system of oral law is so dysfunctional, that within the very first generation, according to the Talmud itself, it has already broken down.
No comments:
Post a Comment